CMP PLANET ANALOG
CMP TAGLINE NEWSLETTER
HOME HOME NEWSLETTER ABOUT ADVERTISING FEEDBACK
News


Events
Discussion
Industry Groups



EE TIMES NETWORK
 Online Editions
 EE TIMES
 EE TIMES ASIA
 EE TIMES CHINA
 EE TIMES FRANCE
 EE TIMES GERMANY
 EE TIMES INDIA
 EE TIMES JAPAN
 EE TIMES KOREA
 EE TIMES TAIWAN
 EE TIMES UK

 EE TIMES EUROPE
 ANALOG EUROPE
 INDUSTRIAL EUROPE
 AUTOMOTIVE DL EUROPE

 POWER DL EUROPE

 Web Sites
 • Audio DesignLine
 • Automotive DesignLine
 • Career Center
 • CommsDesign
 • Microwave
    Engineering
 • Deepchip.com
 • Design & Reuse
 • Digital Home DesignLine
 • DSP DesignLine
 • EDA DesignLine
 • Embedded.com
 • Elektronik i Norden
 • Green SupplyLine
 • Industrial Control
    DesignLine
 • Planet Analog
 • Mobile Handset
    DesignLine
 • Power Management
    DesignLine
 • Programmable Logic
    DesignLine
 • RF DesignLine
 • RFID-World
 • Techonline
 • Video | Imaging
    DesignLine
 • Wireless Net
    DesignLine

ELECTRONICS GROUP SITES

 • eeProductCenter
 • Electronics Supply &
    Manufacturing
 • Conferences
    and Events
 • Electronics Supply &
    Manufacturing--China
 • Electronics Express
 • Webinars


09 February 2010

Why engineers will always be lousy politicians and pundits

The world of analog engineering is the polar opposite of the way that politicians and pundits operate, and that's why engineers don't fit into that public realm
Tony Santiago
Planet Analog
February 2, 2008 (12:00 PM EST)




Its political season here, and the media (both old and new) are filled 24/7 with politicians, pundits, and consultants who are analyzing, assessing, and forecasting. I'm so sick of the meaningless energy dissipation that I have pretty much shut off the TV and radio, and restricted my web sites and surfing time severely.

It's not that I am not interested in these elections in themselves; no doubt, they are important. But when I see the typical behavior and messages of the players, I get major mental aggravation.

Why? First and least offensive is their "spin", putting as good an interpretation on the facts as possible. It's like the old joke about a race: "our guy came in second, while your guy only came in next to last"--but you don't mention that it was just a two-person race!

Second, and more offensive, is the smooth way these people evade questions asked. Imagine your project manager asks, "hey, did you get that dissipation under budget?" and you answer "that's a good question, but instead I'd like to point out that we did get the speed up 20% above plan."

Finally, there's the absolute ease with which these people make predictions and then have no shame or contrition when they are repeatedly wrong. Instead, it's just on to the next prediction. If you modeled system performance and were off by 50%, you'd not only try to figure out why, you'd likely hesitate before making your next bold statement.

This behavior is very far removed from the non-software world of analog designers. When a vendor gives you a sample part and data sheet, you should be able to get the part to do what the data sheet says (assuming you have the proper test setup and expertise). There's no facile, glib suggestion to "ignore our 90 dB SNR claim, but look at that dissipation, and we promise an uncommitted internal op amp, maybe by next quarter."

-x x x-






Related Products
  • Industrial server has 4 PCI Express x4/x16 expansion slots
  • Altium adds Altera Cyclone III to NanoBoard club
  • IBM back in network processor game
  • Bosch unveils integrated MEMS automotive sensor
  • Intel rolls Tukwilla, nixes fully buffered DIMMs

    eeProductCenter



    EE Times TechCareers
    Search Jobs

    Enter Keyword(s):


    Function:


    State:
      

    Post Your Resume
    -----------------
    Employers Area
    Most Recent Posts
    Ascension Health seeking Solutions Development Analyst in St. Louis, MO

    National Semiconductor seeking Principal IC Design Engineer in Santa Clara, CA

    Taylor Guitars seeking Sr. Web Designer in El Cajon, CA

    Covidien seeking Hardware Manager in Boulder, CO

    Sierra Nevada seeking Software Engineer in Hagerstown, MD

    More career-related news, resources and job postings for technology professionals



    Sponsor Links

     

    All materials on this site Copyright © 2010 TechInsights, a Division of United Business Media LLC.
    All rights reserved.
    Terms and Conditions | Privacy Statement | Your California Privacy Rights