Where should that diode go?

Bill Klein, Texas Instruments, Burr-Brown Products Group, Tucson, AZ.

My caller last week had a working system, however, life was not all roses. He had joined the ever-increasing group of engineers using pulse-width-modulation (PWM) drivers. In his case it was to drive a solenoid. Using PWM allowed a significant reduction in power dissipation but it seemed to cause a great amount of noise. His question was simply, “What tricks can I work to reduce the noise caused by the pulse train driving the solenoid?”

After determining that he had a good grounding scheme and the switching currents were not corrupting the analog signals or grounds, I asked about the placement of the fly-back or catch diode. He reported that it was mounted on the solenoid, which was over a foot away from the driver. Here is where the exchange deviated from the normal. Rather than requesting a circuit diagram from him, I sent him the circuit shown here.

The circuit can be modeled with these four elements. When the switch is closed, the Isw equals IL and a magnetic field is developed within the solenoid. When the switch opens the solenoid changes from a load to a source and forces the IL to continue to flow. Therefore, IL is relatively constant while Isw is a pulse train with the noisy switching transients. It is now obvious that if the fly-back diode is located close to the switch element, less noise is radiated.

With this newfound insight he started to look at other areas of his design. Since he was using a low-side-switch topology PWM driver the circuit was actually this.

Why not just let the ESD cell diode function as the fly-back diode? This was an interesting concept but there was a flaw in the design. When the switch is closed the only loss in the circuit is from the switch on-resistance. When the switch opens the forward loss of the diode is the loss element. In addition the switching time of the diode can add significant loss. Therefore, the best operation is obtained when the fly-back diode is low loss and fast. The ESD cell diode has neither of these qualities.

While this particular question was framed around a solenoid driver, a similar situation can exist with a PWM driver from an embedded controller or DSP when driving a filter. In the most extreme case the fly-back diode is replaced with a MOS switching FET that is driven synchronously to with the in-line switch. This is a technique used with the most efficient switching regulators.

Thanks for readingComments Please.
And be sure to copy, you-know,

1 comment on “Where should that diode go?

  1. oiajfoeijf
    July 28, 2015

    1. Talk with recent clients Ask agents to provide a list of what they've listed and sold in the past year, with contact information, says Ron Phipps, past president of the Chicago-based National Association of Realtors, or NAR. Before you start calling the names, ask the agent if anyone will be “particularly pleased or particularly disappointed,” he says. With past clients, “I'd like to know what the asking price was and then what the sales price was,” says William Poorvu, adjunct professor emeritus at Harvard Business School and co-author of “The Real Estate Game: The Intelligent Guide to Decision-making and Investment.” And, if you're the seller, ask if these past properties are similar to yours in price, location and other salient features, Poorvu says. What you want is someone who specializes in exactly what you're selling. SHARE THIS STORY LinkedIn Delicious Reddit Stumbleupon Email story Another good question for sellers is: How long has the home been on the market?

    2. Look up the licensing States will have boards that license and discipline real estate agents in those states, says Phipps. Check with your state's regulatory body to find out if the person is licensed and if there have been any disciplinary actions or complaints, or check to see if the information is posted online.

    3. Pick a winner Peer-given awards count, says Phipps. One that really means something is the “Realtor of the Year” designation awarded by the state or local branch of NAR. “These agents are the best as judged by their peers,” he says. “That's a huge endorsement.”

    4. Select an agent with the right credentials Just as doctors specialize, so do real estate agents. And even generalists will get additional training in some areas. So that alphabet soup after the name can be an indication that the person has taken additional classes in a certain specialty of real estate sales. Here's what some of the designations mean:

    5. Research how long the agent has been in business You can often find out how long the agent has been selling real estate from the state licensing authority. Or, you can just ask the agent. “If they haven't been in business five years, they're learning on you and that's not good,” says Robert Irwin, author of “Tips & Traps When Buying a Home.” Ultimately, what you're looking for is someone who is actively engaged in a particular area and price range, says Phipps. You'll want to know what knowledge of those two factors they can demonstrate and “what kind of market presence they have,” he says.

    6. Look at their current listings Check out an agent's listings online, says Brobeck. Two places to look are the agency's own site and, a website that compiles properties in the Multiple Listing Service into a searchable online database. Most buyers start their search on the Internet, and you want an agent who uses that tool effectively. “A key thing is an attractive presentation on the Web,” says Brobeck. You also can look at how closely the agent's listings mirror the property you want to buy or sell. Are they in the same area? Is the price range similar? And does the agent have enough listings to indicate a healthy business but not so many that you'd just be a number?

    7. Ask about other houses for sale nearby A good agent should know about other area properties that are available “off the top of his head,” says Irwin. Mention a house in your area that's sold recently or is for sale. If the agent knows the property and can give you a few details, that means he or she really knows your area, he says. “You want someone like that who's on top of the market.” 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.